A Mississippi team searched the basement of a courthouse looking for evidence regarding the lynching and murder of Emmett Till, a Black teenager. They found an unsanctioned warrant that charged a White woman with Till’s 1955 kidnapping. Till’s family initiated the search to find Till. Authorities want her to be finally arrested nearly 70 years later.
According to Elmus Stockstill, Leflore County Circuit Clerk Elmus Stockstill, a warrant was issued for Carolyn Bryant Donham’s arrest. The document is identified as Mrs. Roy Bryant.
He said that documents are stored in boxes according to a decade but that there is no other way to determine where the warrant, which was dated August 29, 1955 could have been.
Stockstill certified the warrant to be genuine by saying, “They narrowed the scope between the 50s and the ’60s.
The Emmett Till Legacy Foundation initiated the search and involved two members of Till’s family: Cousin Deborah Watts (head of the Foundation) and Teri Watts. They ask authorities to issue a warrant for Donham’s arrest. Donham was married to one the two White men who were tried and acquitted within weeks of Till being abducted from his relative’s house, murdered, and then dumped into a river.
Teri Watts said in an interview to the AP, “Serve it and Charge Her,”
In August 1955, Donham started the case by accusing Till, then 14, of making inappropriate advances at a Mississippi family store. Till’s cousin who was there said Till yelled at Till, which flew in line with Mississippi’s racist social codes.
Evidence suggests that a woman named Donham identified Till to the men who killed him later. Although Donham’s arrest warrant was made public at that time, the Leflore County Sheriff told reporters that he didn’t want to “bother” Donham because he had two young children to look after.
Donham, now in her 80s, is not commenting publicly on the calls for her trial. Teri Watts stated that the Till family believes Donham’s kidnapping warrant is new evidence.
She stated, “This is what Mississippi needs to do.”
Dewayne Richardson (the District Attorney) declined to comment on the warrant, but cited a December report from the Justice Department about the Till case. It stated that no prosecution was possible.
Leflore County Sheriff Ricky Banks, who was contacted by the AP Wednesday, stated that it was the first time he had heard about a warrant.
Till’s 7-year-old victim Banks said that Till had “nothing to do with a warrant” after a former district attorney looked into the case six or five years ago.
Banks stated, “I will try to get a copy and go with the DA to get their opinion.” Banks stated that if the warrant cannot be served, he would need to speak to the law enforcement officers of the state in which Donham lives.
Arrest warrants can “go old” due to time and changing circumstances. A 1955 arrest warrant would almost certainly not be accepted by a court even if the sheriff agreed to serve it. Ronald J. Rychlak is a law professor at The University of Mississippi.
He said that the original arrest warrant “absolutely”, when combined with any additional evidence, could be a key stepping stone towards establishing probable cause to start a new investigation.
Rychlak stated, “If you were to go in front of a Judge, you could say, “Once upon a Time, a judge determined that there was probable cause. And much more information is now available.
Till was originally from Chicago and was visiting family in Mississippi. He entered the store on August 24, 1955, where Donham was 21 years old. Wheeler Parker, a relative of Till, said that Till whistled at her. Donham said that Till grabbed her and made lewd comments.
Roy Bryant, Donham’s ex-husband and his half-brother J.W. arrived at Donham’s home two nights later. Milam arrived armed at the Leflore County home where Till’s great-uncle Mose Wright was looking for him. Till’s charred body was weighed down by a fan and pulled from a river in another county days later. His mother’s decision of opening the casket to allow Chicago mourners to see the events led to the rise in civil rights.
Bryant and Milam were both acquitted in the murder of Donham, but they later confessed to the crime in a magazine interview. Authorities did not pursue the case after their acquittal, even though both men were listed in the same warrant which accused Donham of kidnapping.
Wright said during the murder trial that Till was taken from his family home by a person who spoke in a lighter voice than Till. FBI files also show that Donham earlier in the night told her husband that at most two other Black men weren’t the right person.
