Judith Thompson’s play, Perfect Pie, presented at the Gwydion Theatre, tells the story of childhood best friends Francesca and Patsy reuniting after a 30-year separation. The play is a memory piece that switches back and forth between the present and the past, depicting the younger versions of the characters in alternating scenes. While the intention of the show is to evoke nostalgia and explore the characters’ past, the constant time changes and numerous scene transitions seem to detract from the overall impact of the story.
The play, directed by Maddie Hillock, features four actors who struggle to maintain a Canadian accent and navigate the shifts between past and present. These transitions often interrupt the flow of the narrative, causing the tension to dissipate whenever the scene changes. As a result, the climax of the story feels less impactful than it could be, losing momentum like a train struggling through deep snow.
Despite these challenges, Sydney Feldman’s performance as Marie stands out as a highlight of the production. Feldman effectively portrays Marie’s transformation from a young girl to a teenager, anchoring the story and bringing focus to the narrative. Her presence on stage helps to ground the play, even amidst the chaotic time shifts and scene changes.
While Perfect Pie has its flaws in execution, there are still strong performances from the cast that elevate the production. However, it’s clear that the script may contain unnecessary material that contributes to the play’s lack of cohesion and impact. As the characters navigate their memories and reunite after years apart, the audience is left to piece together the story amidst the flurry of details and transitions.
In conclusion, Perfect Pie at Gwydion Theatre offers a glimpse into the lives of two childhood friends and their journey of reconciliation. While the play may struggle with maintaining its focus and momentum, standout performances from the cast, particularly Sydney Feldman, bring depth and emotion to the production. Despite its flaws, Perfect Pie remains a poignant exploration of friendship, memory, and the passage of time.
