Barbara Bradley Hagerty, a journalist known for her work connecting religion and criminal justice, embarked on a transformative journey after being forced to leave her radio career due to a paralyzed vocal cord in 2014. Her search for deeper stories and answers about life’s meaning led her to Jim McCloskey, the founder of Centurion Ministries, who had helped exonerate 54 people and shared the story of Ben Spencer with her.
Ben Spencer, a Black man convicted of a crime he did not commit, became the focus of Hagerty’s investigative efforts. Despite years of unsuccessful attempts by Centurion Ministries to secure his release, Hagerty took on the challenge and dedicated seven years to uncovering new evidence and reasons behind his wrongful conviction. Her efforts, including interviewing new witnesses and working with different authorities, ultimately led to Spencer’s release in March 2021.
Hagerty’s book, “Bringing Ben Home,” delves into Spencer’s life and the systemic issues that contribute to wrongful convictions in America. Through Spencer’s story, she highlights various factors such as mishandled evidence, flawed testimony, and the failure to investigate alternative suspects. The book serves not only as a compelling narrative but also as an informative piece shedding light on flaws in the criminal justice system.
Drawing from Spencer’s own words and extensive letters written from prison, Hagerty paints a vivid picture of a man who maintained his innocence and faith despite years of wrongful imprisonment. Spencer’s unwavering belief in his innocence, refusal to admit guilt for parole deals, and assistance in exonerating another innocent man demonstrate his resilience and commitment to justice.
While Spencer’s eventual release after 34 years brings a sense of closure and justice, the underlying issues within the criminal justice system persist. Hagerty raises important questions about the role of luck in determining one’s freedom and the need for systemic reforms to prevent future miscarriages of justice.
As readers journey through Spencer’s story, they are confronted with the harsh realities of wrongful convictions and the enduring impact on individuals and their families. Hagerty’s meticulous research and compelling storytelling make “Bringing Ben Home” a poignant reminder of the flaws in the justice system and the power of perseverance in the face of adversity.